Although the right to trial by jury is enshrined in the U.S. Constitution, in recent years both criminal and civil juries have been criticized as incompetent, biased, and irresponsible. For example, the O.J. Simpson criminal juryas verdict produced a racial divide in opinions about that trial. And many Americans still hold strong views about the jury that awarded millions of dollars to a woman who spilled a cup of McDonald's coffee on herself. Itas said that there are qjudicial hellholesq where local juries provide qjackpot justiceq in medical malpractice and product liability cases with corporate defendants. Are these claims valid? This monumental and comprehensive volume reviews over fifty years of empirical research on civil and criminal juries and returns a verdict that strongly supports the jury system. Rather than relying on anecdotes, Vidmar and Hansarenowned scholars of the jury systemaplace the jury system in its historical and contemporary context, giving the stories behind important trials while providing fact-based answers to critical questions. How do juries make decisions and how do their verdicts compare to those of trial judges and technical experts? What roles do jury consultants play in influencing trial outcomes? Can juries understand complex expert testimony? Under which circumstances do capital juries decide to sentence a defendant to die? Are juries biased against doctors and big business? Should juries be allowed to give punitive damages? How do juries respond to the insanity defense? Do jurors ignore the law? Finally, the authors consider various suggestions for improving the way that juries are asked to carry out their duties. After briefly comparing the American jury to its counterparts in other nations, they conclude that our jury system, despite occasional problems, is, on balance, fair and democratic, and should remain an indispensable component of the judicial process for the foreseeable future.53, 54 Federal Judicial Center, 151 Reference Manual on Scientific Evidence. ... 234 felons and jury duty, 79-80 Fernandes, Steven M., 381 fictitious lawsuits, 347 -48 lawn mower as hedge clipper, 17 slippery floor, ... of the Bill of Rights, 114 Fisher, Michael A., 356 Fishfader, Vicki L., 367 Fletcher, Betty, 237 Fleury-Steiner anbsp;...
|Author||:||Neil Vidmar, Valerie P. Hans|